[Pipet Devel] Piper's Importance and Resources

Nile Geisinger nile at dloo.com
Fri Jun 16 10:17:15 EDT 2000


Hey Jeff,

> Well, Brad has been grumbling about the lack of icons for the Pied/Piper user
> interface.  Has Alex worked with alpha transparencies and PNG's before?

Alex has worked with everything.

> Well, we haven't had an all-out campaign yet, and the main reason is that Open
> Source developers HATE "vaporware".  I guess I thought we should have
> something people can actually use so that they don't get too excited over
> nothing.

More than just hate it. Hate anything they can't download NOW. Three weeks out is
hardly vaporware, but some people on GNOME were a little upset that BlueBox wasn't
available the day it was announced!?!? I guess open source companies are the only
ones that can warn people that software is about to be released.

> When Piper started coming together, I became a bit bewildered by other UNIX
> GUI's, old and new.  I realized that Piper actually brought the UNIX paradigm
> (the USER can do complex tasks by connecting simple tools) to the GUI (and
> desktop) and that NO OTHER SYSTEM (that I know of) has ever really attempted
> this.  GNOME, KDE, Enlightenment, NeXT, CDE, and so on, ARE ALL DERIVATIVES OF
> WINDOWS AND THE MAC, meaning no-one has rethought the concept of the GUI since
> the Lisa and Xerox Star!  I just don't understand it.  The concepts behind
> Piper seem rather obvious.

Good ideas always seem obvious in retrospect.

> > Of these, I could easily see a dozen KDE/GNOME people wanting to
> > contribute if they just understood the potential of your work.
>
> In addition to not wanting to announce vaporware, I thought we needed to
> define Piper's function and implementation before a lot of REAL heavy-weights
> in the community came in and faught over it.....potentially splitting the
> project and/or taking it out of my hands (think bulls in a china shop).  So,
> this has been an incubation period for Piper.

The ASP model is hot. Distributed architecture is hot. Easy interfaces are hot.
Too many ducks are in a row and the fact that two groups already went down a
similar path, probably means that there is a third.

I hope you guys get credit for the ideas in Piper. One always hears that Open
Source only knows how to copy: which is not true. And here, along with FreeVSD,
Freenet, 3dsia, etc., is a clear example of innovation.

> Even during the incubation, source and development have been open.  Piper just

> hasn't been well known.  But, now that it is maturing, I think it can stand
> for some publicity.....and even some fighting over.
>

Multiple visions for a project are often a good thing too. Shows a broad idea that
several people want to use in a variety of ways: witness all the modules  in
Apache. I suspect, when the open source community does becomes aware of it,
there'll be very little fighting, but lots of unintended ways in which Piper
evolves,

cheers,

Nile







More information about the Pipet-Devel mailing list